Posts Tagged ‘public rights doctrine’
FAQ: What would Tax Enforcement look like if the Sixteenth Amendment was enforced consistent with the rest of the constitution and without the aid of the Public Rights Doctrine?
FTSIG ANSWER See: Journey to Sixteenth Amendment, Fed Reserve, FTSIGSection 14: The ONLY Way the Sixteenth Amendment Can Lawfully Be Enforced Based on the Existing Constitutionhttps://ftsig.org/history/journey-to-16a-fed-reserve-nnot/#14._The COPILOT ANSWER QUESTION 1: What would IRS enforcement look like if the Sixteenth Amendment was enforced consistent with the REST of the constitution and didn’t have the benefit of…
Read MorePROOF: Privilege arises from USE of public capacity, not “benefit”
INTRODUCTION: This proof demonstrates and originates the following axiom: Writing Conventions on this Website, 1.2.5. Privilege arises from USE of public capacity, not “benefit”https://ftsig.org/introduction/writing-conventions-on-this-website/#1.2.5._Privilege This proof explains why we call the Public Rights Doctrine a “rent an identity service” on the opening page of this site. Within the FTSIG ontology, the central problem is the…
Read MoreDOCTRINE: Public Rights Doctrine Asymmetry
INTRODUCTION: The Public Rights Doctrine is the basis of the income tax. It recognizes income tax as a “sovereign power” not requiring consent. But there are people recognized in the I.R.C. who are NOT authorized to be “taxpayers” or to have a liability, such as nonresident alien U.S. nationals who do not effectively connect. So…
Read MoreHOW TO: Distinguishing How Constitutional Restrictions are Circumvented Using the Public Rights Doctrine
QUESTION 1: Of the Social Security franchise, the U.S. Supreme Court has said: “We must conclude that a person covered by the Act has not such a right in benefit payments… This is not to say, however, that Congress may exercise its power to modify the statutory scheme free of all constitutional restraint.” [Flemming v.…
Read MoreCopilot: Comparison between Private Right, Public Interest, and Public Right Regulation
INTRODUCTION: Two main Supreme Court Doctrines directly address how PRIVATE property and PRIVATE rights are converted to PUBLIC property and PUBLIC rights respectively. They are: This series of questions compares these two doctrines to provide a comprehensive analysis of how they interact with your PRIVATE property and PRIVATE rights to produce a tax obligation, and…
Read MoreDOCTRINE: How the Government Regulates or Taxes your Private Property: Through the Public Interest Doctrine and Public Rights Doctrine
INTRODUCTION: The Public Interest Doctrine and the Public Rights Doctrine of the U.S. Supreme Court and their relationship to each other and to you are very important to understand because: This series of questions examines how all the above are implemented and how to challenge all the above processes in a court of law. It…
Read MoreDOCTRINE: Defeating the Public Interest Doctrine in Munn v. Illinois
QUESTION 1: What does it mean to be “affected with a public interest” in Munn v. Illinois, 94 U.S. 113: “This brings us to inquire as to the principles upon which this power of regulation rests, in order that we may determine what is within and what without its operative effect. Looking, 126*126 then, to…
Read More